Boone County Environmental Education Center

November 24, 2024

 

Event Directors: Ben Hart and Stephanie Ross

 

Thanks to all volunteers who helped with this event including Guy Olsen (pre-registration – in spite of having hip replacement surgery this week!!), Mike Minium (map printing), Matthew Robbins (download), Amy Lamborg (registration and instruction).

 

Control pickup: Bill Donnelly, Amy Lamborg, Carter Ballard, Mike Minium, Bruce Moore, Diane McKim, Brenda Blacklock, Rob Minto

 

Special Thanks to Lacey Kessell and the staff of Boone County Extension for letting us use their facilities for the event: a beautiful covered shelter building, modern heated restrooms, and open gates that allowed a route choice through the deer-fenced garden.  As usual, OCIN participants and volunteers did a great job of leaving things at least as nice and clean as we found them!

 

After a couple misty, drizzly, chilly days, we had a perfect Sunday for orienteering – mostly sunny and cool, but pleasant for running or walking through the steep woodlands of the Boone County Extension Environmental and Nature Center.

 

Several orienteers on brown, green, and red courses were fooled into mis-punching at their number 3 control.  Was it fair?  Here is the analysis.  Controls are supposed to be a minimum of 30 meters apart (at normal forest events), or at least 60 meters if they are on similar feature.  The controls on the map were 42 meters apart.  The #3 control was at a junction of 2 small erosion gullies, and was placed pretty low – you could not see it until you got close.  The other control was on white course at a stream/trail crossing.

 

So the question becomes, were they similar?  I believe that a jury at a national ranking event would uphold the placements as fair.  From #2 (also in a small erosion gully), to get to the correct control, you had to go downstream along the left side of the ditch (which became the stream), but staying well to the left of the main stream to get to erosion gullies which drained into it from that side.  The incorrect control was along the main stream, requiring a further descent along the main stream.

 

Several factors contributed to the mistake.  The distances between the 3 controls were all very short.  Leaving control #2, there was a large area of fallen trees which blocked the most desirable route of immediately going left of the ditch and contouring the slope to the left of the stream.  You had to either climb higher to the left, or stay to the right of the stream for a ways, then cross back over.   If you went right of the stream, as soon as you left 2, you could immediately see the incorrect control along the stream below you, and the immediate tendency was to run straight to it, forgetting that you needed to cross the stream, stay to the side of the main stream valley, and not descend quite so much.  It was an easy mistake to make, especially after having done a fast trail run to 1 and 2, ascending the hill to 2 – just enough hard exertion to be pulling blood flow to the muscles and away from the brain – a time to focus and be really careful.   Additionally, when you got to the incorrect control, the trail was mostly covered by dead leaves, so it might not have immediately registered that you were on a trail that shouldn’t be there.

Leaving the incorrect control toward 4 probably also set off some easily ignored alarm bells – you wouldn’t see the trail you expected to cross (because you’d already crossed it), and you’d spot 4 sooner and farther to the left than expected.  But again, its easy to ignore those additional warnings!   See the course images on the Livelox link above to see the relative positions of the controls.

 

 

TROL (youth) season standings

 

WARS (adult) season standings

 

Livelox – (Dylan Poe)

 

Route Gadget – (Beth MacLehose) coming soon.

 

Photos from this event

 

Results by Courses

 

Split Times by Course

 

Split Times by Age Class

 

Results by Age Class

WhiteTrolPS-F (4)

1 White

1.9 km

11 Controls

 

Place

Stno

Name

Club

Time

Diff.

 

1

62

Eloise Ramadanovic

Union County MS

1:05:08

0:00

1

59

Lilly Vail

Union County MS

1:05:08

0:00

 

45

Bridget Rollins

Union County MS

mp

61

Bree Gonyer

Union County MS

mp

 

 

 

 

WhiteTrolPS-M (1)

1 White

1.9 km

11 Controls

 

Place

Stno

Name

Club

Time

Diff.

 

1

6

Jamison Cooper

Union County MS

27:50

0:00

 

 

 

 

WhiteOpen (2)

1 White

1.9 km

11 Controls

 

Place

Stno

Name

Club

Time

Diff.

 

1

69

Aaron Smith

OLOU

16:44

0:00

2

14

Justin Feaster Geeta Ganesh Vikram Feas

OLOU

52:51

+36:07

 

 

 

 

YellowTrolMS-M (3)

2 Yellow

2.4 km

15 Controls

 

Place

Stno

Name

Club

Time

Diff.

 

1

20

Clark Hand

Home School

25:47

0:00

2

13

Jason Feaster

Meyzeek MS

35:57

+10:10

3

2

Carter Ballard

Union County MS

55:45

+29:58

 

 

 

 

YellowOpen (2)

2 Yellow

2.4 km

15 Controls

 

Place

Stno

Name

Club

Time

Diff.

 

1

39

Joan Ragusa

OCIN

40:25

0:00

2

15

Susan Frazier

OCIN

1:11:43

+31:18

 

 

 

 

OrangeTrolJV-F (1)

3 Orange

2.8 km

19 C

 

Place

Stno

Name

Club

Time

Diff.

 

67

Joselyn Dunlap

North Oldham MS

mp

 

 

 

 

OrangeF (1)

3 Orange

2.8 km

19 C

 

Place

Stno

Name

Club

Time

Diff.

 

1

50

Laura Ruwe

OCIN

2:37:33

0:00

 

 

 

 

F55+ (2)

4 Brown

2.6 km

16 C

 

Place

Stno

Name

Club

Time

Diff.

 

1

58

Laurie Sydzyik

OCIN

46:21

0:00

 

3

Valerie Benton

OCIN

mp

 

 

 

 

F65+ (1)

4 Brown

2.6 km

16 C

 

Place

Stno

Name

Club

Time

Diff.

 

1

71

Victoria Huseman

OCIN

2:16:21

0:00

 

 

 

 

M65+ (4)

4 Brown

2.6 km

16 C

 

Place

Stno

Name

Club

Time

Diff.

 

1

26

Warren Mandrell

OCIN

47:09

0:00

2

44

Dave Robinson

OCIN

1:16:16

+29:07

3

17

Bill Greenwell

OCIN

1:24:58

+37:49

4

34

Charles Nash

OCIN

2:00:28

+1:13:19

 

 

 

 

M75+ (1)

4 Brown

2.6 km

16 C

 

Place

Stno

Name

Club

Time

Diff.

 

1

16

Robert Frey

OCIN

1:12:46

0:00

 

 

 

 

BrownF (1)

4 Brown

2.6 km

16 C

 

Place

Stno

Name

Club

Time

Diff.

 

1

41

Ellen Richey

OCIN

1:14:00

0:00

 

 

 

 

BrownM (2)

4 Brown

2.6 km

16 C

 

Place

Stno

Name

Club

Time

Diff.

 

1

43

Matthew Robbins

OCIN

1:01:23

0:00

2

31

Kevin Mitchell

OCIN

1:15:31

+14:08

 

 

 

 

GreenTrolV-M (3)

5 Green

3.9 km

20 C

 

Place

Stno

Name

Club

Time

Diff.

 

1

18

Jared Grissom

Union County HS

57:14

0:00

2

38

Dominic Ragusa

Home School

1:07:58

+10:44

3

63

Dylan Gonyer

Union County HS

1:16:19

+19:05

 

 

 

 

F35+ (1)

5 Green

3.9 km

20 C

 

Place

Stno

Name

Club

Time

Diff.

 

1

70

Isis Espinosa

OCIN

2:07:55

0:00

 

 

 

 

F45+ (6)

5 Green

3.9 km

20 C

 

Place

Stno

Name

Club

Time

Diff.

 

1

47

Stephanie Ross

OCIN

1:05:56

0:00

2

19

Theresa Grissom

OCIN

1:12:32

+6:36

3

27

Diane McKim

OLOU

1:30:10

+24:14

4

23

Amy Lamborg

OCIN

1:30:29

+24:33

5

4

Brenda Blacklock

ICO

1:34:08

+28:12

 

51

Mimi Ruwe

OCIN

dnf

 

 

 

 

M55+ (6)

5 Green

3.9 km

20 C

 

Place

Stno

Name

Club

Time

Diff.

 

1

55

Shin Shimizu

COO

57:39

0:00

2

29

Michael Minium

OCIN

58:53

+1:14

3

48

Tim Rouse

OCIN

1:18:55

+21:16

4

28

Paul Merchak

OCIN

1:34:15

+36:36

5

12

David Faller

OLOU

1:40:36

+42:57

 

32

Bruce Moore

OLOU

mp

 

 

 

 

GreenM (4)

5 Green

3.9 km

20 C

 

Place

Stno

Name

Club

Time

Diff.

 

1

24

Jonathan Madden

OCIN

1:18:36

0:00

2

8

Jason Day

OCIN

1:30:02

+11:26

3

57

Jonathan Stevens

OCIN

1:30:19

+11:43

4

36

Ryan Owens

OCIN

1:38:30

+19:54

 

 

 

 

GreenGroup (1)

5 Green

3.9 km

20 C

 

Place

Stno

Name

Club

Time

Diff.

 

1

33

Kenta Tsuchida Taro Morimitsu

None

1:34:36

0:00

 

 

 

 

GreenOpen (2)

5 Green

3.9 km

20 C

 

Place

Stno

Name

Club

Time

Diff.

 

1

21

Benjamin Hart

OCIN

49:11

0:00

2

65

Bolanos Rosenbaum Bolanos

None

2:19:44

+1:30:33

 

 

 

 

F-21+ (1)

6 Red

5.0 km

24 C

 

Place

Stno

Name

Club

Time

Diff.

 

54

Chiori Shimizu

COO

mp

 

 

 

 

M-20 (4)

6 Red

5.0 km

24 C

 

Place

Stno

Name

Club

Time

Diff.

 

1

66

Ian Dunlap

North Oldham HS

41:56

0:00

2

10

Alex Eriksson

West Lafayette Jr-Sr HS

45:11

+3:15

3

52

Ethan Scobee

OLOU

1:09:27

+27:31

4

49

Parker Routt

OLOU

1:41:21

+59:25

 

 

 

 

M35+ (4)

6 Red

5.0 km

24 C

 

Place

Stno

Name

Club

Time

Diff.

 

1

68

Ryan Dunlap

OLOU

50:06

0:00

2

1

Brian Baker

OLOU

1:03:35

+13:29

3

56

Aaron Smith

OLOU

1:09:34

+19:28

4

42

Joseph Richey

OCIN

1:12:39

+22:33

 

 

 

 

M45+ (3)

6 Red

5.0 km

24 C

 

Place

Stno

Name

Club

Time

Diff.

 

1

30

Robert Minto

ICO

1:08:26

0:00

2

9

Bill Donnelly

OCIN

2:51:09

+1:42:43

 

5

Michael Bordner

OCIN

mp

 

 

 

 

M-21+ (3)

6 Red

5.0 km

24 C

 

Place

Stno

Name

Club

Time

Diff.

 

1

11

Mattias Eriksson

ICO

47:19

0:00

2

40

Jasper Ralinovsky

OCIN

54:36

+7:17

3

64

Daniel Clepper

OCIN

1:41:06

+53:47

 

 

 

 

 

results of next OCIN event (Miami University, Dec 1)

 

results of previous OCIN event (Diamond Oaks, Nov 16)

return to 2024 Results index

return to OCIN home